← Articles
How we actually decide a score

How we actually decide a score

June 16, 2026 · Jonas Halvorsen

People ask us how the numbers happen, so here's the honest version. A score on Pocket Verdict isn't a formula. It's the result of several of us playing the same game and then arguing about it.

We start by agreeing what a game is trying to be. A quiet puzzle game and a sprawling strategy title can't be judged by the same checklist, so we grade each against its own ambitions.

Then we play past the honeymoon phase. Lots of games are charming for twenty minutes. We care about hour three and hour ten, when the systems have shown their hand and the novelty's worn off.

You'll notice we rarely give below 3.8 — that's because we don't bother publishing reviews of games we'd never recommend to anyone. If something's genuinely broken, we just move on rather than waste a page on it.

A score is a shorthand. The words around it carry the real verdict, so please read those too.

behind the scenesratings